Below are covers that I created for the Pitsco STEM and Math Expedition Titles. For more information about Pitsco Expeditions, go to www.pitsco.com.
STEM Expeditions offer flexibility
Whole-class and rotational models enable teachers to work in comfort zone
By Cody White, Communications Assistant
cwhite@pitsco.com
cwhite@pitsco.com
PITTSBURG, KS – When teacher Caleb Boulware was approached to beta test Pitsco’s new STEM Expeditions curriculum in his eighth-grade science classroom at Pittsburg Community Middle School, he was enthusiastic. He embraced the ideals of the Expeditions right away.
At the same time, he was hesitant. Boulware had facilitated Modules previously, and, though he respected the platform, he wished for more flexibility in implementation. The structure hadn’t been quite the right fit for his teaching style. He knew he was being invited to help make the STEM Expeditions into the best solution they could be, and he knew that providing tough – even blunt – criticism would be part of that.
Of the curriculum Pitsco has produced, Modules stand apart, having the weight of a dynasty. Boulware understood he was being asked to lend himself to the creation of what could be a new dynasty, and to his credit he recognized this as not a light decision. Even after he agreed to beta test the STEM Expeditions, he inwardly hoped he would be up to the task of providing the kind of difficult criticisms that were being asked of him. His breakthrough moment came all at once.
“One morning I was reading in the Bible the scripture that iron sharpens iron, and that is what opened me up. I won’t be doing Pitsco justice if I’m not honest.”
Now, deep in the beta test, Boulware is on the phone with Pitsco writers practically every day, letting them know what works for his students and what needs work. Though (spoiler alert) he loves the STEM Expeditions, he understands that he and others must dig deep now to make the Expeditions truly be all they can be when they reach teachers across the country in Fall 2016.
FLEXIBLE
The cornerstone of the STEM Expeditions is the powerful flexibility of the curriculum. The Expeditions are designed to be implemented either rotationally or in a whole-class fashion. The rotational scheme works much as Modules do – student pairs proceeding through one Expedition after another within a seven-day rotational window, with separate pairs working through different titles.
However, the whole-class implementation is what appealed to Boulware. In this scheme, the students still work in pairs, but all are working on the same project simultaneously. Teacher-led instruction is an essential component, blending with the student-led portions. In this, the teacher has the freedom to control the flow of the unit.
“We spent an entire day off the Expeditions to work on Ohm’s law,” said Boulware, “breaking it down on the board and doing a test and a worksheet over it. We spent another whole day talking about series and parallel circuits.”
Teachers who embrace student-led discovery but who still wish to guide the class together and customize the experience might prefer the whole-class implementation. Teachers who wish for a more thoroughgoing student-led model with diverse projects occurring simultaneously might prefer the rotational implementation. Of course, both implementations have at their core hands-on projects, critical thinking, data gathering, and problem solving. Neither is absolutely preferred. The demands of the classroom and the educator’s preference determine the proper path. But Boulware didn’t have to pause – he knew it was the whole-class scheme that he favored.
“I liked the concept because everybody is on the same page. We’re not doing five different things at one time. Everybody’s doing the same thing at the same time. I love that.”
ENGAGING
It’s a mild late-winter morning, and the lively eighth graders in Boulware’s class are using multimeters to test wind turbines they constructed on a previous day. Students are noting results in their logbooks and recording the data in tables and graphs, which must themselves be interpreted.
“It makes me work,” says Cooper, a student. “It doesn’t give you the answers clearly. . . . It gives you information about what to do to get the information. It doesn’t tell you what to graph. It just gives you hints about what to do.”
In this way, students are pushed to understand the concepts, not to just parrot them. Reflecting on his experience, Boulware remarks that there is no way for students to game the system. “If they aren’t listening to the Expedition, they are done.”
Student Kiven agrees about feeling pushed. “(In this title) you have got to assemble the turbines and do a whole bunch of experiments with them. This is testing our limits.”
Students are conditioned for problem solving and critical thinking, and this means more teacher freedom. Eighth grader Austin perceptively considers the Expeditions from a teacher’s standpoint. “It doesn’t require a teacher to be standing behind you when another kid has a genuine question or needs help.”
RIGOROUS
The STEM Expeditions are challenging. Practically every student in Boulware’s class brought up this point. Now here is a fact that might surprise those who are pessimistic about the ambition of today’s students: the vast majority of those students indicated they appreciated this challenge. The reason is clear. The students are making the connection between their work in the Expeditions and their own futures.
Logan, looking toward a math-intensive future in computer design, reported, “When we started, we had no idea how to interpret data. This is getting us to the point where we can.” Kiven, his partner, chimed in on the point, “It’s something we’ll need to know when we go to high school.”
They aren’t wrong. The Expeditions are correlated to a robust set of standards, calculated to help a teacher get at those hard-to-reach places.
“The fact that it meets math, ISTE, NGSS, and ELA standards,” said Boulware, “we’re meeting standards that need to be met. Math, NGSS, and ISTE, I can do that. ELA, I can’t. They are not my strength.” But the Expeditions give him the power to focus on his strongest areas and the comfort of knowing that the other essential skills are still being addressed.
At its most fruitful, rigorous education not only inspires students to think of the relevance to their own futures but also prompts them to think of the world around them. The Urban Wind Farm unit compelled student Austin to think about the realities of wind technology. “I talked to my family about the viability of wind farms. I think it is definitely something interesting to talk about. Done right, it could save money.”
WORLD IN MOTION
The realities of the classroom continually evolve. Expectations change, and needs change too. The Expeditions grew from what teachers have told Pitsco are their needs. Pitsco’s success depends on this insight from its partners – educators. They move forward together because the challenge is too great for any one person or organization to meet alone. Pitsco pools its expertise to create new solutions and along the way trusts in the wisdom and the integrity of teachers providing feedback.
Pitsco has learned a great deal from the beta testing comments from teachers such as Boulware (and their students as well, who have been encouraged to critique the Expeditions at every turn). Among other things, his comments have led to planned improvements in the teacher’s version of the logbook, adding more resources. The Expeditions aren’t in their final form yet, but the core is here and the rest is being polished now.
“Once the wrinkles are fixed, I love the Expeditions,” said Boulware. “I can honestly say I don’t even like them, I love them. . . . If I were to leave the middle school and become a principal somewhere, the Expeditions would be something I would push in my departments.”
Additional STEM Expeditions articles: